5100 Harborage DrThe Harborage · Fort Myers, FL 33908
$725,000

There is a ski course in the lake behind this house.

Eighty feet of frontage on Harborage's private water-ski lake, with a dock and lift already in the water. The main floor sits 11 feet 10 inches above grade and has never taken water inside, Hurricane Ian included.
3 Bed + Den 3 Full Baths 1,982 Sq Ft Built 1987 Lakefront · Dock & Lift 4-Car Garage
List Price
$725,000
Price / Sq Ft
$365.79
Lot Size
12,894 sq ft
HOA Dues
$4,000 / yr
The Home

Waterfront you can actually afford, in a neighborhood that does not usually allow it.

Harborage is a gated community of roughly 130 homes built around private lakes, with a boat ramp, a beach, and a ski course that belongs to the residents. Nothing else here is listed under $879,000. This one is $725,000.

You walk in on the upper level and the ceiling opens straight up. Vaulted throughout, walls of windows across the back, and the lake sitting right there in every one of them. The kitchen was taken down to the studs and rebuilt: a long center island with bar seating, a glass tile backsplash, a walk-in pantry, and custom built-in shelving. Living, dining, and kitchen share one room, and the sliders open onto a deck that runs the width of the house over the water.

The primary suite has its own door onto that deck. Dual vanities, a separate tub and shower, a walk-in closet. Two more bedrooms, a den, a dedicated media room with a drop-down screen, and a workshop fill out a split two-story plan, and one of the bedrooms with a full bath sits on the entry level. Three full baths total, which is the difference between hosting people and hosting people comfortably.

Downstairs is the part boaters stop at. Four garage bays with epoxy floors, plus an enormous covered space underneath the house where a long table and a dozen chairs sit in the shade all summer. Beyond that, a paver fire pit ring on the grass, an outdoor shower, and the dock.

The house is 1987 and the county puts its effective year at 1993, but almost nothing you touch is that old. Flooring, kitchen, baths, paint, and fixtures have all been redone. Appliances date to 2022. The air conditioner and water heater went in in 2019, and the sprinkler pump this year. The dock and the lift are newer than any of it. Lee County first put the pier on the tax roll in 2023.

Room For A Pool

There is no pool here today. This is what one could look like.

Every buyer who stands on that back lawn starts doing pool math in their head, so rather than leave you guessing at it, the sellers had a designer draw the yard three ways. The three images below are artistic renderings. They are not photographs, and nothing they show has been built.

Artistic Rendering Artistic rendering, not an actual photograph. A possible future pool, spa, paver deck, and outdoor kitchen in the back yard at 5100 Harborage Drive, shown in daylight. None of it exists on the property today.
1. Midday
Artistic Rendering Artistic rendering, not an actual photograph. The same possible future pool, spa, and outdoor kitchen shown at sunset with landscape lighting. None of it exists on the property today.
2. Sunset
Artistic Rendering Artistic rendering, not an actual photograph. The same possible future pool, spa, and outdoor kitchen shown after dark. None of it exists on the property today.
3. After dark
What is real in those images and what is not.

Real, and included in the sale: the lake, the dock, the boat lift and its canopy, the elevated deck, the covered space underneath the house, and the lot itself. Everything else you see is drawn. There is no swimming pool, no spa, no outdoor kitchen, no grill, no outdoor television, no paver decking, no landscape lighting, and no string lighting on this property today. The furniture and the plantings are illustrative. None of it is included in the sale, and nothing here is a commitment by the sellers to build any of it or contribute toward it.

If you want to price the real version, say so and we will send your contractor the survey with the lot lines and the easements on it. The lawn between the deck and the water is where it would go.

See the back yard as it actually is today

The Water

Two kinds of boating, and they work differently. Here is the honest version.

People see "waterfront boating community" and assume one thing. Harborage is better than that in one direction and more particular in another, so it is worth ten seconds of explanation before you drive out.

From your own dock

Your dock, lift, and canopy sit on East Lake, which is fresh water and private to the community. There is a slalom course set in it. This is where the skiing, the wakeboarding, the kayaks, the paddleboards, and the evening cruise happen, and you step off your back lawn to do any of it. Motorboats run at idle within 150 feet of any shoreline, so the lake stays usable rather than chaotic. Nobody outside Harborage has access to it.

The dock is deeded and included in the sale, along with the lift and the canopy over it.

To the Gulf

The Gulf boat does not live on this lake. It launches at the community ramp in Harborage's own boat yard, which puts you in the 10 Mile Canal and from there to the river and out to Estero Bay. No bridges to clear on the way. The listing puts the open Gulf at roughly twenty minutes.

The sellers report the shallowest point of that route at about two feet, so draft matters. If you run something with a deep keel, ask us and we will get you the depths in writing before you write an offer. Trailer storage in the boat yard is a separate space you apply for, and the association's rules put the decal at $130 a year for a resident's first space.

Read this part twice. Your dock fronts a freshwater lake rather than a Gulf-connected canal, and the MLS classifies the Gulf access here as Other for that reason. Gulf boating here runs through the community ramp, not off your back yard. That distinction is exactly why a lakefront home with a dock in Harborage costs what this one costs instead of what a direct-access canal home costs. Whether that trade works for you depends on which boat you actually use most.
Elevation, Flood, and Ian

It sits high, and it has the record to show for it.

The living level of this house is 11 feet 10 inches above grade. Everything you live in is up top, and what is underneath is garage, storage, and covered patio. That is not a design accident. It is how the Southwest Florida waterfront was built before people forgot why.

Hurricane Ian is the test everything around here gets measured against. On their signed disclosure the sellers state that during Ian water entered the garage and the crawlspace, and no water entered the living area. That disclosure is posted below, unedited, along with their separate flood disclosure reporting no flooding damage, no flood insurance claim, and no FEMA assistance during their ownership.

FEMA maps the parcel as Zone AE with a base flood elevation of 11 feet, on panel 12071C0576H effective November 17, 2022. A lender will require flood insurance in Zone AE. The sellers carry a policy through Selective Insurance, and per the listing that policy transfers to the buyer, which in a market where new coverage is repriced from scratch is worth asking your agent about early rather than late.

Open the FEMA flood map (PDF)

FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer map showing 5100 Harborage Dr in Zone AE with a base flood elevation of 11 feet, panel 12071C0576H
Video

What it is like to live down here.

This is an area tour rather than a walkthrough of the house. Martin filmed it around Fort Myers, Fort Myers Beach, and Sanibel, which is the stretch you are ten to twenty minutes from at this address. The photos above cover the home itself. Turn the sound on. The file is large, so nothing downloads until you press play.

Where This Price Sits

Everything else for sale in Harborage starts at $879,000.

You are going to look this up anyway, so here it is. This is every home listed in Harborage and every Harborage sale from the past year, pulled from the Southwest Florida MLS on July 22, 2026. Read it with one thing in mind: this house is the smallest floor plan of the group, and it is priced accordingly.

For sale in Harborage right now

5100 Harborage, this home1,982 sq ft · built 1987 · lakefront with dock and lift$725,000
5160 Harborage2,459 sq ft · built 1991 · on the market 384 days$879,000
5350 Harborage2,608 sq ft · built 1989$900,000
5561 Harborage2,612 sq ft · built 1994 · on the market 320 days$925,000
5460 Harborage4,327 sq ft · built 1991 · on the market 719 days$1,999,000
The next cheapest way into this neighborhood is $154,000 more.And three of the four have been sitting for most of a year.

What Harborage sold for in the last year

5411 Harborage 2,374 sq ft, built 1987 · 116 days · June 2026$720,000
5030 Harborage 2,197 sq ft, built 1990 · 28 days · March 2026$819,000
5381 Harborage 2,609 sq ft, built 2001 · July 2026$875,000
5541 Harborage 4,093 sq ft, built 2003 · July 2026$995,000
Four sales, twelve months$720K to $995K

The closest thing to a match is 5411 Harborage, also a 1987 build, roughly 400 square feet larger, which closed at $720,000 in June after 116 days. Harborage does not turn over quickly. Four sales in a year across the whole community is the normal rate here, so when the one you want comes up, waiting for a better one is a longer bet than it sounds.

Source: Southwest Florida MLS, comparative market analysis run July 22, 2026. Listing status and days on market change. Ask us for a current pull before you make a decision on price.

The Lot and the Structure

What the county actually measured.

There is no floor plan drawing on this listing, so rather than guess at room sizes, here is the Lee County Property Appraiser's own breakdown of the building along with the 2011 boundary survey. Both documents are posted in full below.

Heated Living Area
1,982 sq ft
Lower Garage, Finished
1,110 sq ft
Lower Covered Porch
307 sq ft
Finished Open Porch
78 sq ft
Total Area
3,092 sq ft
Lot Dimensions
80 × 170
Lake Frontage
80.19 ft
Effective Year Built
1993
2011 boundary survey of Lot 9, The Harborage, showing the two-story building, wood deck, covered area, and 80.19 feet of frontage on East Lake

The survey is dated June 20, 2011, so it shows the house, the deck, the covered area underneath, and the lot lines, but it predates the pier the county added to its record in 2023. Lot 9 fronts East Lake, Tract B, with a 20-foot maintenance easement along the water and 6-foot easements down both sides.

Three quarters of an acre it is not. This is a .30-acre lot, 80 feet wide and 170 feet deep, and the house is placed toward the street so the lawn between the deck and the water is open and usable. The fire pit sits out there.

Download the Survey (PDF)

What You Get

Dates, not adjectives.

Every item below comes from the sellers' own information sheet, their signed property disclosure, the listing data, or the Lee County building record. If a date is not known, it is not listed.

Systems and appliances, with the year they went in
  • Refrigerator, range, dishwasher, microwave, washer and dryer: all 2022.
  • Air conditioner and water heater: 2019. Central electric, with ceiling fans throughout and an exhaust fan.
  • Sprinkler pump: 2026, this year. Irrigation draws from the lake rather than the meter.
  • Roof: 2007 concrete tile. On their disclosure the sellers report it structurally sound and free of leaks, with one repair on record. A small leak at a plumbing vent boot was resealed.
  • No water softener and no well. Water and sewer are both Lee County Utilities, and both assessments are paid.
The water side: dock, lift, shoreline
  • Private dock, deeded, included in the sale. Boat lift with a canopy cover over it.
  • Pier added to the county record in 2023, so the dock structure is recent.
  • Outdoor shower at the base of the stairs, which is the thing you appreciate about four minutes after you get out of the lake.
  • Community boat yard for the trailer and the second boat, plus the community ramp to the canal.
Storm and structure
  • Living level 11 feet 10 inches above grade, with garage and storage below.
  • Manual storm shutters, full coverage.
  • Concrete block and wood frame construction under a tile roof. Exterior is stone, stucco, and vinyl siding.
  • Double hung and picture windows.
  • Two stories, split level, with the lower garage finished at 1,110 square feet across four bays and epoxy on the floor.
Inside
  • Vaulted ceilings in the main living space, vinyl plank flooring throughout, no carpet.
  • Kitchen rebuilt with a large center island and bar seating, walk-in pantry, glass tile backsplash, custom built-in shelving, electric cooktop, and a self-cleaning oven.
  • Primary bath with dual sinks and a separate tub and shower. Walk-in closets.
  • A dedicated media room with a drop-down projection screen, a den or study, a workshop, a laundry room inside the residence, a balcony, and an open lanai.
  • Fireplace, on the county record since the house was built.
  • First-floor bedroom with a guest bath, which solves the stairs problem for visiting parents.
  • Paver patio, added to the county record in 2017, and a paver fire pit ring on the lawn.
  • Cable and internet prewired, smoke detectors, automatic sprinklers, auto garage door.
What the sellers disclosed, in their own words

The full signed disclosure is posted below. The two items they wrote in by hand:

  • During Hurricane Ian, water entered the garage and the crawlspace. No water entered the living area.
  • A small leak at one of the plumbing vents through the roof was resealed.

Read the whole form before you write. It is four pages and it takes five minutes.

Open the Seller's Property Disclosure

The Real Monthly Numbers

What it actually costs to live here.

Most listings make you guess at this. These are the sellers' own reported figures from their information sheet, alongside the 2025 Lee County tax bill and the association's approved 2026 budget. Your loan terms, your insurance, and your tax bill will all differ from theirs, so read the totals as an illustration and not a quote.

Estimate your payment

$—
principal & interest

Illustrative only. Rates and programs vary by lender and by borrower. This is not a loan offer or a quote.

The rest of the monthly picture

Property taxes sellers' 2025 bill, $3,272.34, with homestead. See the note below.$273
HOA dues Harborage, $4,000 billed once a year on January 1$333
Electric FPL, sellers' reported average$250
Flood insurance Selective, sellers' reported figure. Policy transfers per the listing.$215
Water and sewer Lee County Utilities, sellers' reported average$80
Internet Xfinity, internet only$80
Trash and recycling assessed on the tax bill above, $348.75 a year$0
Gas, pool service, security monitoring none of the three apply here$0
Reported costs before the loan$1,231

Not in that total Homeowners insurance. The sellers carry a policy through Loggerhead, and rather than publish a premium we have not verified line by line, ask us and we will send you the current declarations page. Also not in the total: lawn care, which the sellers ran at $100 a month through Lynn's Lawncare and are not currently using, and boat yard storage at $130 a year if you want a space for the trailer.

Your tax bill will not look like theirs, and the gap is large.

The sellers homestead this property. Save Our Homes has held their assessment at $270,978 against a market value of $370,962, and after $50,722 in exemptions their taxable value is $220,256. That is how a $725,000 waterfront home carries a $3,272 tax bill.

Florida resets the assessed value when a property sells. Using the 2025 Lee County millage of 13.2950 against a $725,000 assessment, with no exemption in your first year, the ad valorem taxes land near $9,639, plus the $348.75 solid waste assessment. Call it roughly $830 a month rather than $273. If you homestead it the following year, the exemptions bring it down some and the cap starts protecting you from there. Run your own number with the Lee County Property Appraiser before you set your budget, and treat the $273 above as history rather than forecast.

One-time costs the association charges at closing.

A $150 transfer fee and a $125 application fee, both payable by the buyer under the recorded HOA disclosure. Association approval of the buyer is required, so build the approval window into your contract dates. The disclosure and the registration form are both posted below.

Sources: the sellers' Frequently Asked Questions sheet, the 2025 Lee County tax bill and 2025 TRIM notice, the Lee County Property Appraiser record, the recorded HOA community disclosure, and The Harborage Owners' Association approved 2026 budget. All of them are posted below.

Preferred Lender

Buying this home starts with knowing your numbers.

Cary Meyers, Guild Mortgage

Cary Meyers

Guild Mortgage · Southwest Florida

Cary works this market and gets buyers pre-approved fast, with a straight answer on the monthly number. A 1987 elevated home in Zone AE with a transferable flood policy has a couple of underwriting details worth raising in week one rather than week three. Call him for a rate quote or to start a pre-approval.

(616) 915-2366 · cmeyers@guildmortgage.net

Apply now with Cary Meyers at Guild Mortgage

Click to get pre-approved or start your application.

Cary Meyers NMLS #584519 · Guild Mortgage NMLS #3274 · Equal Housing Opportunity. You are welcome to finance this purchase with any lender you choose.

The Harborage

A boating neighborhood that built its own lakes.

Harborage is gated, private-road, and small. The association bills 129 lots in its 2026 budget and the listing describes it as a 130-home community. Everything the residents share sits inside the gate: a community pool, a community center, a tennis court, a pickleball court, a basketball half court, a playground, walking trails, a sand beach on the lake, the boat yard, and the ramp.

Dues are $4,000 a year, paid in one payment on January 1. Of that, $3,186.05 runs the place and $813.95 goes to reserves. The 2026 budget is posted below and it is worth a look, because the association funds reserves at $105,000 a year on a fully funded plan rather than the thin approach a lot of Florida communities took and are now paying for. Landscaping, tree work, irrigation, lake and waterway maintenance, beach renourishment, trail upkeep, sidewalks, the gate, the pool contract, common-area insurance including flood, and professional management all come out of the same $4,000.

Leasing is restricted, and it is stricter than the MLS field suggests. Under the recorded covenants, no leasing during your first two years of ownership unless the board grants a written hardship exception, then a maximum of three leases per calendar year with a six-month minimum term and a one-year maximum. All leases need board approval. If you are buying this as a rental, read Section 9 of the covenants before you write.

Location is the quiet argument for this address. You are about twenty minutes from Fort Myers Beach and Sanibel, close to RSW, and a short drive from Gulf Coast Town Center and Coconut Point. Rayma C. Page Elementary is the zoned elementary school. Lee County runs school choice for middle and high, so assignment there is not automatic.

Community
Gated · ~130 homes
HOA Dues
$4,000 / year
Roads
Private, paved
Elementary
Rayma C. Page
Leasing
3/yr · 6-mo min
Pets
No approval needed
HOA2026 Approved BudgetLine by line, plus the reserve funding plan HOAAssociation DocumentsThe full set, with an index HOALake Use RulesWho can use the lakes, and how HOABoat Storage Area RulesDecals, spaces, and what is allowed in the yard
Do Your Homework Here

Every document, before you even ask.

Serious buyers want the paperwork early, and holding it back has never once helped anybody. It is all here, including the full association file. Read it, then come walk through it.

Lee County Property Appraiser Record Open in Apple Maps Open in Google Maps
See It In Person

Schedule a showing.

Martin and Kim Hawley
Martin & Kim Hawley, REALTORS®
The Hawley Team at KW Florida Living · Keller Williams Realty
Martin (239) 355-4040 · Kim (239) 420-9027 · martin@teamhawley.com
The Hawley Team at KW Florida Living

The owners still live here and there is a pet in the house, so showings run by appointment rather than walk-in. Give us a little notice and we will get you in, most often the same day or the next morning. It is a gated community, so we will need your name at the gate ahead of time. Already working with an agent? Have them call and we will take it from there.

Ready?

Make an offer.

A dock and lift on a private ski lake, a four-car garage, a living level almost twelve feet up, and the lowest price in the neighborhood by $154,000. Here is exactly how to write on it, with nothing hidden in the process.

  1. Use the Florida AS-IS Residential Contract. Your agent will know it. If you do not have an agent, call us and we will walk you through your options.
  2. Attach your mortgage preapproval, or proof of funds if you are paying cash.
  3. Include the signed disclosures from the documents section above. The seller's property disclosure, the flood disclosure, and the HOA community disclosure all need to ride along with the contract.
  4. Build the association approval window into your dates. Harborage approves the buyer, and there is a $125 application fee and a $150 transfer fee at closing.
  5. Email the package to martin.hawley@kw.com. Every offer gets a confirmation, and every offer gets presented.
Start Your Offer Email Questions First? Call Martin
Call Text Schedule Showing
Listing photo, full screen
Artistic rendering, not an actual photograph. No pool, spa, or outdoor kitchen exists on the property today.